Selling sports cards can be a fun and profitable hobby or even a full-time business. However, many sellers—especially those just starting out—fall into common traps that hurt their sales, profits, and reputation. Whether you’re flipping cards on eBay, running an online store, or selling at card shows, avoiding these mistakes can help you maximize your success.
Here are the top five mistakes sports card sellers make—and how to avoid them.
1. Underpricing (or Overpricing) Cards
One of the biggest mistakes sellers make is mispricing their cards. Setting prices too low means you leave money on the table, while pricing too high discourages potential buyers.
How to Avoid It:
- Research recent sales on platforms like eBay (use the “Sold” filter to see actual selling prices).
- Compare your cards to others in similar condition and grading.
- If you’re unsure about a card’s value, start with an auction at a competitive price rather than guessing.
Bonus Tip: I once underpriced a rookie card of a rising star because I didn’t check recent trends—by the time I realized, the card had doubled in value! Always check current market demand.
2. Neglecting Proper Packaging
A great sale can quickly turn into a refund request if a card arrives damaged due to poor packaging. Sellers often use flimsy envelopes, skip protective sleeves, or fail to secure the card properly.
How to Avoid It:
- Use penny sleeves and top loaders for individual cards.
- Secure cards between cardboard or inside team bags before shipping.
- Use bubble mailers for added protection and avoid plain white envelopes (PWEs) unless selling very low-value cards.
Bonus Tip: Buyers remember good packaging! I’ve had repeat customers just because they appreciated how well I packed their cards.
Here are the items I use for preparing and packaging cards to be shipped.
3. Ignoring Market Trends
The sports card market is constantly evolving. What was a hot card last month might not be in demand today. Many sellers make the mistake of not keeping up with trends and missing opportunities.
How to Avoid It:
- Follow sports news, rookie performances, and trade rumors—these impact card values.
- Use social media, YouTube, and forums like Blowout Cards to stay updated.
- Be willing to adjust pricing or inventory strategy based on trends.
Bonus Tip: A few years ago, I held onto a batch of Zion Williamson rookie cards, thinking they’d keep rising in value—unfortunately, injuries tanked his market demand. Always stay flexible!
4. Failing to Build a Reputation
Inconsistent customer service, slow shipping, and poor communication can hurt your reputation. Sellers who don’t prioritize their buyers often see fewer repeat customers and lower ratings.
How to Avoid It:
- Ship quickly and communicate tracking details.
- Respond to messages promptly and professionally.
- Offer fair return policies to build trust.
Bonus Tip: I once turned an unhappy buyer into a repeat customer just by handling an issue quickly and fairly. A good reputation leads to long-term success!
5. Not Diversifying Selling Strategies
Relying on just one method of selling (like only using eBay) can limit your reach and profits. Many sellers don’t explore alternative platforms, local markets, or creative sales strategies.
How to Avoid It:
- List cards on multiple platforms (e.g., eBay, Facebook Marketplace, Whatnot, and Instagram).
- Consider running auctions for fast sales and fixed-price listings for premium cards.
- Experiment with mystery packs, bulk sales, or card shows to expand your options.
Bonus Tip: Some of my best deals have come from local collectors at card shows—don’t rely solely on online sales!
Final Thoughts
Avoiding these common mistakes will help you become a more successful sports card seller. Pricing correctly, protecting your shipments, staying informed, maintaining good customer relationships, and diversifying your strategies can all contribute to long-term profitability.
If you’re looking to improve your sports card sales game, start implementing these tips today! Got a mistake you’ve learned from? Share it in the comments below!
Looking for more tips on selling sports cards? Check out our latest guides and resources at maxman101.com!
MaxMan101 Sports Cards 
Leave a comment